idsurfer wrote in post #18564521
What started as a simple comment really got blown out of proportion. I decided to step away from the conversation and just let it be after DaviSto's last comment. It really isn't that big of a deal. IMO, to each his own with regards to their opinions about what is appropriate when posting. Who's really to say what is right or wrong?? If it is blatantly offensive the mods can sort it out.
Having said this I'm compelled to reply to your comment which sure has an aggressive and vindictive tone.
1. I don't agree that "Nice set up or Cool shot" is critique in it's usual sense. It's simply a positive comment.
2. I do think it's okay to make positive comments. I am of the opinion that unless the posting member is asking for CC, than I only make positive comments.
3. I don't even understand what you might be suggesting by me going to a quiet corner, blah, blah, blah....
I think you are trolling. We let this go a couple days ago. Why do you feel the need to stir the pot?
I've been following this and I'm not stirring the pot, but this is something that comes up a lot in photography groups and I can't help but think how strange a world it is when its somehow inherently implied that only positive comments are permitted, as that such a weird form of censorship usually reserved for more child like environments.
I don't have a point really, but its something that I wanted to say, I guess I find it funny how situations like this even arise, and personoally I'd much prefer people to tell me what they thought, as opposed to only seeing platitudes, as that gives a false sense of worth to me. This is how we end up with what I call X-Factor syndrome, where all anyone does is give praise, you then end up on TV in front of a panel of people who are paid to be brutally honest and we've all seen how that can end.