Okay, you guys are not making it any easier on me. I thought I had it narrowed down to two, until I posted this.
Anyway, I went to a local camera shop and played around a bit. They didn't have either of the two I was looking for in stock. They did have a Sigma 30 and I must say, it was very nice. Probably not L or Zeiss build quality but still a very nice lens. f/1.4 seemed usable (compared to my 50 where f/1.4 seems soft).
This got me wondering, how is f/1.4 on the 35L? I was leaning towards the Zeiss, but the more I think about it, the more I think I might want AF and the option of using f/1.4 (if it is acceptable).
Thanks again for all of the help and keep the responses coming!