Rate the Photo Above You

tsfall wrote in post #13895003
Image noise and lack of detailing in peoples faces is frustrating, nice colours in the lanterns. Little bit busy for my liking, but I'm a stickler for single details 6/10

IMAGE LINK: http://www.flickr.com/​photos/foolery/5866062​021/
Catching Air by \~{Foolery}~/, on Flickr

Unusual position of jeep but missing something for me 6/10

HOSTED PHOTO
please log in to view hosted photos in full size.

7/10 Like the detail on the bell itself, but it feels like its lacking something... I think I would like it more if the bike was re-positioned. Still a nice Shot!!

dsit995 wrote in post #13897242
7/10 Like the detail on the bell itself, but it feels like its lacking something... I think I would like it more if the bike was re-positioned. Still a nice Shot!!
[IMG]

7.5/10 - Nice atmosphere, bokeh looks good. I have that x-mas feeling again.

IMAGE LINK: http://www.flickr.com/​photos/jvk031/59954050​17/

jvk wrote in post #13897432
7.5/10 - Nice atmosphere, bokeh looks good. I have that x-mas feeling again.

strange... my first thought was not good about this photo , i was like... composition is bad, it s empty... and i saw the bar on the top of the photo... finally nice composition, the jumper, the bar... did she success or fail ? i like it. 7.5/10

IMAGE LINK: http://www.flickr.com/​photos/elboubou/687345​3083/

Beautiful girl but the lighting isn't optimal at all. Bright background and dark subject. Not sure what the branches (?) that are sticking out in the front are either. 6.5/10

HTTP response: NOT FOUND | MIME changed to 'image/gif' | Redirected to error image by FLICKR

gh8st wrote in post #13897207
Unusual position of jeep...

I'd say this was a USUAL position of a Jeep, and that driving down a busy shopping street or dropping the kids off at school is an UNUSUAL position for a Jeep!

Bend The Light wrote in post #13900709
I'd say this was a USUAL position of a Jeep, and that driving down a busy shopping street or dropping the kids off at school is an UNUSUAL position for a Jeep!

that’s how we use Jeeps too haha

the photo above me its not available ill do the rate as soon as its available again
Heres mine

Nice idea but its a shame the foreground is so out of focus. Bit lacking in contrast too i reckon. 5/10

IMAGE LINK: http://www.flickr.com …jackhenriques/6​865818403/

[QUOTE=jack880;1390396​6]Nice idea but its a shame the foreground is so out of focus. Bit lacking in contrast too i reckon. 5/10

Thanks for the advise ^^

Now, that is SUPER sharp! Great composition, great photo overall. It won't get a 10/10 just because of the flare on the top right, but make it a 9.9999999999/10

I am new to photography and I dont have much to "critique" yet. Here is a shot I like from my visit to Honolulu. I took this shot from the boat on my way to the Pearl Harbor memorial. Please let me know what you think.

Canon T3i with 18-55mm Kit lens + Polarizing filter

6/10. Composition needs some work and in my opinion the processing is really heavy - lighten it up a bit and tone down the vignette.

Another NYC shot for you guys:

IMAGE LINK: http://www.flickr.com …/davidmadison/6​884138329/

Nice! I like the contrast between the sky and foreground. The composition is nice too. Simple but effective. 8/10

IMAGE LINK: http://www.flickr.com …/68488447@N05/6​879098361/

I really like the drama the dark clouds give above the valley. Black and White was perfect for this picture!