Rate the Photo Above You

RishabhSood wrote in post #17112041
Give you a 9/10 picture is amazing!

IMAGE LINK: https://www.flickr.com …07138035@N05/14​970217871/
Rachael B&W by BradRumble Photography, on Flickr

Nice, I like how the picture looks, good light on her face. 8/10

Sorry mate, just looks like a snapshot to me. Not sure why it's black and white... 3/10

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/oN26​vr

jack880 wrote in post #17112193

Sorry mate, just looks like a snapshot to me. Not sure why it's black and white... 3/10

you give a 3/10 without explanation ? Can you develop ? what's wrong with snapshop ?
You're not sure why it's B&W, don't speak about it ... it's B&W because it's a very sad moment, did you take a look at the scene ? people are crying, look at the story in the bokeh.

I don't know why there is a blue hue in the above black and white photo.. Also, I feel the bokeh doesn't really work here and makes for a less strong photograph. The way the people in the background look, it looks as if the two people were blown out and the only reason why this photo is in b+w is to save the ruined photo.. I might have given it a 3/10 myself. Just my opinion.

hyogen wrote in post #17112617
I don't know why there is a blue hue in the above black and white photo.. Also, I feel the bokeh doesn't really work here and makes for a less strong photograph. The way the people in the background look, it looks as if the two people were blown out and the only reason why this photo is in b+w is to save the ruined photo.. I might have given it a 3/10 myself. Just my opinion.

But you explain why

Reservoir Dog wrote in post #17112670
But you explain why

<3 I love your signature statement regarding the watermark... soooo true in most cases My watermark a year and half ago was ridiculously big.

jack880 wrote in post #17112193

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/oN26​vr My Head in My Hand by J_Q_H, on Flickr

Quite the photograph here. I'm guessing it's been done before (not original), but very well done nonetheless. Correct me if I'm wrong. There is a weird shadow on the right hand in the bottom half of the photo.. I don't really like the colors, but I guess that it works in this particular photo. 8.5/10

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/oRWd​sT

hyogen wrote in post #17112617
I don't know why there is a blue hue in the above black and white photo.. Also, I feel the bokeh doesn't really work here and makes for a less strong photograph. The way the people in the background look, it looks as if the two people were blown out and the only reason why this photo is in b+w is to save the ruined photo.. I might have given it a 3/10 myself. Just my opinion.

I understand the photo might look like a snapshot, however I personally like it because it shows the emotions of the bride and her father, they both are crying because after the end of the day they will be going to separate homes.

I'm not the one who called it a snapshot I just think it was a poorly executed photo. The bokeh doesn't enhance the photo at all in this case in my opinion. Can anyone figure out what that blue splotch is? The bokeh doesn't look like there is a smooth transition, almost as if this is a composite... But anyway, we're all here for honest opinions right?

Reservoir Dog wrote in post #17112267
you give a 3/10 without explanation ? Can you develop ? what's wrong with snapshop ?
You're not sure why it's B&W, don't speak about it ... it's B&W because it's a very sad moment, did you take a look at the scene ? people are crying, look at the story in the bokeh.

Huh? This forum is for people to express their own opinions about photos - particularly photos that are posted specifically for people to comment on. I don't like this one. To me it's boring and I don't see how the lack of colour makes it any less boring. I have seen other photos by RishabhSood which are much better, but that is only my opinion.

hyogen wrote in post #17112702
Quite the photograph here. I'm guessing it's been done before (not original), but very well done nonetheless. Correct me if I'm wrong. There is a weird shadow on the right hand in the bottom half of the photo.. I don't really like the colors, but I guess that it works in this particular photo. 8.5/10

Thanks a lot for the rating. If it has been done before i haven't seen it! I had the idea myself after sitting for a couple of hours working out what i wanted to do!

hyogen wrote in post #17112702
Quite the photograph here. I'm guessing it's been done before (not original), but very well done nonetheless. Correct me if I'm wrong. There is a weird shadow on the right hand in the bottom half of the photo.. I don't really like the colors, but I guess that it works in this particular photo. 8.5/10

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/oRWd​sT HYO_3167-4 by www.HYOFOTO.com, on Flickr

I love the expressions. Looks a tad over exposed in the highlights to me. Something about it being central 'annoys' me, but that's probably just me. 6.5/10

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/oSqh​z1

jack880 wrote in post #17113044
Huh? This forum is for people to express their own opinions about photos - particularly photos that are posted specifically for people to comment on. I don't like this one. To me it's boring and I don't see how the lack of colour makes it any less boring. I have seen other photos by RishabhSood which are much better, but that is only my opinion.

Thanks a lot for the rating. If it has been done before i haven't seen it! I had the idea myself after sitting for a couple of hours working out what i wanted to do!

The reason why I said that is because the idea is so cool--it *has* to be un-original since there are so many geniuses out there...hahaha. More kudos to you for doing something you've never seen before and maybe you are the first--definitely not to be the last now

sancho1983 wrote in post #17113307
I love the expressions. Looks a tad over exposed in the highlights to me. Something about it being central 'annoys' me, but that's probably just me. 6.5/10

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/oSqh​z1 Play by the sancho, on Flickr

Love this as a black and white great focus and composition. Looks great all around 9/10

^^^very photogenic but I think the flash is a bit flat, maybe place or bounce the flash for softer lighting on her face! 7/10 congrats !!!

here is my photo of a leaf just hanging on a single spider web which i removed

meeko031 wrote in post #17115351
here is my photo of a leaf just hanging on a single spider web which i removed

I really like this Gives the illusion you've snapped its while floating through the air ^_^ Maybe a little too much space to the left.
7/10

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/oT9h​sJ

chocolatekara wrote in post #17115606
I really like this Gives the illusion you've snapped its while floating through the air ^_^ Maybe a little too much space to the left.
7/10

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/oT9h​sJ IMG_0719 by chocolatekara, on Flickr

I think there are a lot of good things about this image; conversion, dof, focus but I may have cropped it differently (given the option) as my eye is drawn to her nose as it remains. The strengths make up for any personal nitpicks 7.5/10

This is my first attempt at a double exposure