Rate the Photo Above You

nqjudo wrote in post #17361597
I've looked at this photo quite bit since you posted it. I like it a lot. The reflection is really nice and I like the compositions and colours. The only thing that keeps distracting me is that small patch of lights on top of the hill (mountain) just right of centre. I probably would have cloned it out. My eye keeps getting pulled there. Would have been a 10 without it but this one still gets a 9.

Here are a few young monks from SE Asia. Myanmar I think.

love the comp of this very well put together the lighting is nice and the DOF is perfect.. 8/10

Not bad - nice and sharp, but not that interesting to me. Highlights could be reduced a bit too.

6/10

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/qnaj​Dh

While I love dilapidated buildings there's something about this that seems to say there is too much going on. I am drawn more towards the better lighted room to the right than the room with the phallic symbol drawn on the wall. Not a big fan of the vignetting either... 7.5/10 Only because I know what it's ike to walk into places like these. So much to shoot in so little time.

This is my take on dilapidated buildings. This is a stairwell in an old abandoned church in Gary, IN. Fascinating place to visit. There were 3 or 4 floors. The higher I climbed the more snow there was inside the building.

Sorry, doesn't really do much for me - I like the shallow DOF with just the eyes in focus but it's a little overexposed and not interesting to me. Still better than a lot of photos on here though!

6/10

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/qDxA​Xa

nqjudo wrote in post #17363760
Now that is how you photograph the interior of a dilapidated building. Nice composition and very good processing. Silver Efex? 8/10

From around the Taj:

i like the framing here... awesome use of symmetry the building in the back is a bit blown out and i know u cant control the ppl in the background but had they not been there it def would of been suberb... 6/10

^^very nice capture not a fan of the snake but love the composition and framing 8/10


Reflection

Good photo. Wonder how it would look in landscape. The spots at the bottom on the water maybe should've been cloned out. Pity the traffic in front of it. 7/10

This is photo no. 4 in my new 365 Project. I went for an creative self portrait.

Very cool shot cubatahavana! Definate subject. Very sharp( on my phone). Good comp. I would have warmed it up a tad. But great photo. 8.5/10

This is from downtown bakersfield. Testing out my new sigma 10-20mm on my new 70d. Love the camera and the sharpness it produces.

I'm too slow
Lol

Varneeezy wrote in post #17365685
I'm too slow
Lol

At least the man got an average score of 8.75 from the both of us. Not bad!! LOL!

nqjudo wrote in post #17365681
This is a really nice photo. Very creative. I appreciate how the objects on the table act like a frame and move your eye toward the sketch. 9/10 IMO. On a side note I wish I could draw that well. I can't even sign my own name the same twice.

It's edited from a different self portrait. A blend of 3 different photos. I can't draw at all myself!

like the intensity of the stare, but kinda foggy...better in color? 6/10

Great compostition and exposure, I think the framing and perspective are great. Subject is a little lacking 8/10

Got a winter full moon shot last night in the blistering cold!

Nice moon shot, sharp and well exposed, but not sure why there's so much space around it (excuse the pun)? i think a tighter crop would work better.

7/10

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/qngr​NK

jack880 wrote in post #17369153
Nice moon shot, sharp and well exposed, but not sure why there's so much space around it (excuse the pun)? i think a tighter crop would work better.

7/10

IMAGE LINK: https://flic.kr/p/qngr​NK Photo Frame by J_Q_H, on Flickr

I like the composition, the post processing is good (only the sepia that i do not like, but it's only a matter of personal taste, i think i have a problem with sepia , i prefer "pure" B&W)
I like to see the ceiling "falling down" too, it give more story to the picture.
Over all, it's a nice picture, well done !
8/10